2026 Patreon Episodes

Check out each of our 2026 Patreon Episodes Below!

Episode 44 ~ Laurie Show (Part 1)

Today, we dive into a case fueled by teenage emotions and complicated relationships. We’ve talked before — relationships can be a rollercoaster. And for teens who struggle to regulate their emotions, that ride can sometimes take a dark turn.

Lisa Michelle Lambert had been terrorizing Laurie Show for months. She believed Laurie had tried to steal her boyfriend — but in reality, Laurie was a victim of sexual assault. Months of this harassment escalated from cruel words to terrifying violence, setting the stage for tragedy.

Episode 45 ~ Laurie Show (Part 2)

Check out part 2 of Laurie's case!

Episode 46 ~ Steven Brian Pennell & Anne Marie Fahey

This month's Beyond the Keystone is a double case. Join us as we discuss Delaware serial killer Steven Brian Pennell and the disappearance of rising Delaware political player, Anne Marie Fahey.

Episode 47 ~ Mary Ann Mitchell

This episode takes us back to 1959 and the disappearance of Mary Ann Mitchell after a night out with her friends. They hit the Roxy theater then grabbed food. A wonderful way to spend the Christmas break. Afterwards the girls headed separate ways to get home. Two of the girls walked while Mary Ann waited for the bus. She was only a short 10 minute commute from getting home safe and sound. Unfortunately our stories never end up that way.

Episode 48 ~ Interview with Jessica Freeman's Sister

We're thrilled to be bringing you some extra content this month. You may have seen on our main feed, Episode 192 on Jessica Freeman. Chelsea interviewed her sister Carlina, and you can find that conversation here!.

Episode 49 ~ Kevin Powell & Steven Adams

Join Chelsea & Shannon as they discuss the must be sunshine state, Florida. Though our case isn’t sunny but quite bleak. We all know so many are drawn to Florida for vacation and for permanently living there. Not just for retirement but young families. That was the case for Kevin Powell & Stephen Adams. They were looking for a community to call their own which led them to Wilton Manors.

They were able to build a wonderful community, make friends, enjoy their careers but in the process of setting roots, they found a monster. Someone who the couple felt they could trust turned out to be their demise.

Episode 50 ~ Aaron Turner & Malinda Hoagland

Another double episode! We are going to Coatesville to cover two separate cases: Aaron Turner and Malinda Hoagland. Both cases involve minors, so listener discretion is advised.

Episode 51 ~ Debbie Randall

In 1972, an innocent nine-year-old girl was kidnapped just steps from her home, violently raped and strangled to death, Over the 50 years since her death, there have been no leads and three of the four original detectives on the case died before it was solved.

The killer has never been found – until now.

Episode 52 ~ Dawn Momohara

We are going Beyond the Keystone, to the beautiful, tropical state of Hawaii! This island paradise is what dreams are made of, at least that's what one may believe. However, like all states, Hawaii has a dark side and today's the team discusses the murder of Dawn Momohara.

Episode 53 ~ David L Grove

Today’s case takes us to Fairfield, a small borough tucked into Adams County to the murder of David L Grove, wildlife conservation officer.

Episode 54 ~ Joann and Alex Katrinak

What happens when a young mother and her 15-week-old baby vanish without a trace? We are discussing the 1994 disappearance and murder of Joann Katrinak and her nearly 4-month-old son, Alex.